These are documented cases, as reported by a US regulator and by journalists. They describe what happened at the time.
Internet providers
In 2021, staff at the US Federal Trade Commission reported on several large internet providers. They found that many combined browsing and app data to target ads, and that even providers who promised not to sell data still let it be used and monetized by others. The disclosures were often buried in fine print.[1]
AT&T GigaPower
In 2015, customers of AT&T's GigaPower fiber service who did not want their web browsing used for advertising paid about $29 more per month.[2] AT&T later dropped the extra charge.[3]
Avast
Avast is known for antivirus software and browser extensions. The FTC alleged that from 2014 to 2020, Avast sold people's browsing data through its subsidiary Jumpshot to more than 100 third parties. In 2024, Avast agreed to pay $16.5 million to settle, and it is banned from selling browsing data for advertising.[4]
Free VPN apps
Researchers have also looked at free VPN apps. One 2026 analysis of 18 popular free Android VPN apps found advertising trackers in 17 of them. The analysis was published by MysteriumVPN, itself a VPN company, and reported by Security Affairs.[5]